Thrifting and consignment shopping have become very popular ways to find amazing deals on high-quality items. Across the state of New Jersey, there excellent selection of thrift and consignment stores where you can uncover hidden gems and vintage treasures.

This article will highlight the 25 best thrift stores in New Jersey that are scattered across the Garden State. Whether you’re looking for affordable clothing, furniture, home goods, or just want to go treasure hunting, these are the top-rated thrift stores you must visit in 2024.

Key Takeaways

Northern New Jersey Thrift Stores

1. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center – Paramus

The Paramus location of The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center is located at 545 Route 17 South. The store is open Monday-Saturday from 9am-8pm.

This massive thrift store has a huge selection of clothing, furniture, books, toys, linens, and more. Prices at The Salvation Army tend to be very low, making it an extremely affordable place to shop. The selection is vast, with many high-quality goods in great condition. The store is well-organized with items sorted neatly by category. Shopping here is an enjoyable treasure hunt through aisles of housewares, electronics, books, clothing, and more.

The Salvation Army is known for its 50% off sales which can make the already low prices seem like an absolute steal. The store has an extremely helpful donation center, making it easy to drop off your gently used items to support the organization.

Yelp reviewers consistently mention the amazing prices and selection at this location. One happy customer said, “This place is absolutely awesome! A wide variety of items from clothing to furniture to housewares. The prices are unbeatable – everything is in great shape and so affordable!”

2. Goodwill Industries of Greater New York and Northern New Jersey – Jersey City

The Jersey City Goodwill is located at 101 22nd St, with hours of operation Monday-Saturday from 9am-9pm and Sunday 10am-6pm.

This massive thrift store has two floors filled with just about everything imaginable. Shoppers can find clothing, accessories, books, home goods, electronics, furniture, and more. The prices at Goodwill are extremely affordable, while still offering high-quality merchandise. The selection here is enormous, with many designer and name brand items mixed throughout the store. The atmosphere is clean, organized, and easy to shop.

Goodwill frequently has 50% off color tag sales, making the already low prices even more budget-friendly. The Jersey City location supports job training programs for people with disabilities and other challenges to employment in the local community.

According to Google reviews, shoppers consistently find amazing deals on luxury brands at this Goodwill. One happy customer raved, “I’ve furnished half my apartment with fab finds from this place! Amazing selection of home goods and clothing at such insanely cheap prices.”

3. New Leaf Consignment – Maplewood

New Leaf Consignment is located at 174 Maplewood Ave in Maplewood, NJ. The shop is open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am-5pm.

This upscale consignment store specializes in contemporary women’s clothing, handbags, shoes, and accessories. The items stocked at New Leaf are very high-end, often including designer brands like Gucci, Louis Vuitton, Burberry, and more. The merchandise is in pristine, like-new condition. The shop is selective about the items they accept for consignment, so shoppers can trust they will find quality pieces here.

Prices at New Leaf Consignment are significantly discounted compared to retail prices but are higher than a typical thrift store. The shop offers additional discounts during sales events. New Leaf has a clean, boutique-like atmosphere with neatly organized racks and shelves of fabulous finds.

According to Yelp, New Leaf is known for carrying a wide variety of contemporary, trendy styles from high-end designers. Happy shoppers gush over the excellent bargains they’ve scored on luxury items here.

4. DoubleTake Luxury Consignment – Hoboken

DoubleTake Luxury Consignment is conveniently located at 120 Washington St in downtown Hoboken. The store is open 7 days a week from 11am-7pm.

As a high-end consignment boutique, DoubleTake hand selects designer clothing, shoes, bags, jewelry, accessories, and home goods. Shoppers can browse through Chanel, Prada, Hermes, Louis Vuitton and other luxury brands.

Prices here are at least 50% off retail, so savvy shoppers can nab designer deals. New inventory arrives daily, giving frequent visitors a reason to stop by often. The shop is neatly organized with a luxe, boutique feel.

According to Google reviews, DoubleTake is known for having an amazing selection of contemporary designer items in like-new condition at a fraction of the retail cost. Happy consignment shoppers love scoring designer deals here.

5. The Salvation Army Family Store & Donation Center – Newark

This Newark Salvation Army location is at 393 Market St. It’s open Monday-Saturday from 9am-7pm.

The Newark store has a vast selection of clothing, furniture, electronics, books, housewares, and everything in between. Prices at The Salvation Army are extremely budget-friendly. The selection here is enormous across all categories. The large store is neatly organized by item type.

Like all Salvation Army locations, the Newark store has 50% off deals on certain days. Donating to The Salvation Army is easy with a drive-up donation center in the back. Proceeds from purchases support local community programs.

According to Yelp, this Salvation Army outpost is known for its unbeatable prices and vast selection across all product categories. One happy reviewer said, “You can find amazing bargains on furniture, clothing, books – pretty much anything you need!”

Central New Jersey Thrift Stores

6. Save and Rave Consignment – Lawrenceville

Save and Rave Consignment is located at 301 Gordon Ave in Lawrenceville. The shop is open Tuesday-Sunday from 10am-6pm.

This two-story consignment store has a wide variety of contemporary clothing and accessories for the whole family. Categories include women’s, men’s, juniors, kids, shoes, handbags, and jewelry. The shop also stocks toys, books, small appliances, furniture, and home decor.

As a consignment store, prices are discounted 30-50% off estimated retail price. New inventory is added daily from their network of local consignors, so there’s always something new. The store has a clean, organized layout that’s easy to browse.

According to Yelp, Save and Rave is known for its amazing selection of affordable, stylish clothing and constant influx of new inventory. Happy shoppers love the great deals to be found here.

7. Goodwill Industries of Greater New York and Northern New Jersey – Princeton

The Princeton Goodwill is located right in downtown at 203 Nassau St. It’s open Monday-Saturday from 9am-9pm and Sunday from 10am-6pm.

Given its proximity to Princeton University, this massive thrift store gets amazing donations and is frequently visited by bargain-hunting college students. There is great selection across all categories including clothing, furniture, electronics, books, home goods, and more.

As a Goodwill, prices on everything are extremely affordable. New merchandise comes out continually throughout the day. The store has a neatly organized layout that makes hunting for hidden gems enjoyable.

According to Google reviews, this Princeton Goodwill location has become hugely popular thanks to its incredible selection and rock-bottom pricing. As one happy shopper put it, “This place is thrifting paradise!”

8. America’s Attic – Red Bank

America’s Attic is located at 2 Bridge Ave in Red Bank. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 10am-5pm.

This two-floor thrift store is loaded with clothing, accessories, books, toys, housewares, and more. The shop specializes in cool vintage and retro finds from the 50s, 60s, 70s, and beyond.

Prices at America’s Attic are very affordable, while still being selective about quality and condition. The shop has a neat, curated feel with merchandise organized by era and style. Shoppers can expect to encounter many one-of-a-kind pieces.

According to reviews, America’s Attic is known for its cool throwback selection and inventory of unique vintage items you can’t find elsewhere. One delighted customer raved, “This place is vintage shopping heaven! I found the perfect funky retro dress for an upcoming 70s party here.”

9. Blue Jean Baby – Trenton

Blue Jean Baby is located at 1407 Whitehorse Mercerville Rd in Trenton. They are open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am-5pm.

This specialty resale shop focuses on maternity clothes, baby items, and children’s clothing. Expect to find a wide selection of maternity wear, bassinets, strollers, nursery furniture, toys, books, kids’ clothes and more.

Prices at Blue Jean Baby are very reasonable, given the specialty nature of the inventory. The selection focuses usefulness over trendiness. The store’s layout is neatly organized by item type and size.

According to Yelp, Blue Jean Baby is beloved for its amazing selection of quality maternity and children’s items at affordable resale prices. One happy mom said, “I furnished my nursery and stocked up on maternity clothes for a steal here!”

Southern New Jersey Thrift Stores

10. Second Time Around – Mount Laurel

Second Time Around is located at 67 Centerton Rd in Mount Laurel. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 10am-8pm and Sunday from 11am-5pm.

This family-owned consignment chain carries contemporary women’s, men’s, and juniors’ clothing and accessories. Shoppers can browse categories including tops, dresses, pants, coats, handbags, shoes, jewelry and more.

As a consignment store, prices are a discounted 30-50% off estimated retail. New consignments are added weekly, so there’s always new items hitting the racks. The store is neatly organized by size and type.

According to Google reviews, Second Time Around is loved for its selection of on-trend fashions at discounted consignment prices. As one happy shopper put it, “Awesome finds at even more awesome prices!”

11. Goodwill Industries of Southern New Jersey – Cherry Hill

The Goodwill of Southern NJ store in Cherry Hill is located at 1018 Haddonfield Rd. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 9am-9pm and Sunday from 8am-8pm.

This massive thrift store has a huge selection across all categories including clothing, shoes, accessories, books, home decor, electronics, furniture, housewares, toys, and more. As a Goodwill, prices on everything in the store are extremely affordable.

New inventory comes out continually throughout the day. The store has a very clean, neatly organized layout to make treasure hunting easy. As one of Goodwill’s donation centers, it helps fund job training programs.

According to Yelp reviews, this Goodwill location is acclaimed for its amazing prices and constantly replenished selection across all departments. One delighted customer raved, “I furnished my entire dorm room in one trip here!”

12. Mainstream Boutique – Audubon

Mainstream Boutique is located at 812 West Nicholson Rd in Audubon, NJ. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 10am-5pm.

This upscale consignment shop specializes in contemporary women’s clothing, shoes, handbags and accessories. The focus is trendy styles from premium brands like J.Crew, Anthropologie, Madewell, and more.

As a consignment store, prices are discounted 30-50% off retail prices. New items are added to the sales floor daily. The boutique has a clean, modern feel with items neatly organized by category.

Yelp reviewers rave about Mainstream’s curated selection of on-trend designer styles at steep discounts. One delighted customer said, “I’m addicted to hunting for deals on premium brands here!”

13. Uniquities Thrift Store – Sewell

Uniquities Thrift Store is located at 500 Delsea Dr in Sewell. They are open Monday-Saturday from 10am-6pm.

This non-profit thrift shop carries gently used furniture, clothing, jewelry, books, collectibles, housewares, and home decor. Pricing is very affordable, with student and senior citizen discounts on certain days. New donations are put out daily.

The store benefits local charities supporting children, veterans, and families in need. Uniquities has monthly 50% off sales offering even deeper discounts. The store is neatly organized with aisles clearly sorted by category.

According to Google reviews, Uniquities is known for its affordably priced selection benefiting great causes in the community. One happy customer raved, “Awesome finds, amazing prices, supporting my community – love this place!”

Jersey Shore Area Thrift Stores

14. Goodwill Industries of Southern New Jersey – Toms River

The Toms River Goodwill store is conveniently located at 1126 Hooper Ave, near the Jersey Shore. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 9am-9pm and Sunday from 10am-7pm.

This large thrift shop carries a wide variety of clothing, shoes, home goods, furniture, books, toys, electronics and everything in between. As a Goodwill store, the prices are extremely affordable across all departments.

New donations are brought out daily here, so frequent visitors will encounter new items every time they browse. The store has a clean, orderly layout that makes treasure hunting a breeze.

According to Yelp, this Goodwill location is perfect for bargain shoppers visiting the Jersey Shore. One pleased customer raved, “Awesome finds, even better prices. A must-stop whenever I’m down the shore!”

15. Main Street Mission Thrift Store – Asbury Park

Main Street Mission Thrift Store is located right downtown at 1504 Main St in Asbury Park, NJ. Their hours are Monday-Saturday from 9am-5pm.

This thrift shop carries a wide range of merchandise including clothing, shoes, accessories, books, toys, games, housewares, small appliances, furniture, and home decor. As a non-profit, prices are very affordable.

Sales are held frequently, making the already low prices even more budget-friendly. New donations are put out regularly. The store has a neatly organized layout for easy browsing. Proceeds benefit Main Street Mission’s local community outreach programs.

According to Google reviews, this mission-driven thrift store is a great spot to uncover amazing deals while vacationing in Asbury Park. One happy customer said, “Found everything I needed for my beach rental here – at awesome prices!”

16. America’s Attic – Point Pleasant Beach

America’s Attic in Point Pleasant Beach is located right downtown at 1013 Arnold Ave. They are open Monday-Sunday from 10:30am-5:30pm.

As the Jersey Shore outpost of the popular central NJ thrift chain, this two-floor shop carries a wide range of clothing, accessories, housewares, furniture, home decor, and more. There is a strong emphasis on unique vintage, retro, and antique finds.

Pricing is affordable while still being selective about condition and uniqueness. New stock is put out daily. The store has a neat, curated layout allowing you to stumble upon unexpected treasures.

According to Yelp, America’s Attic Point Pleasant has an amazing selection of beachy and vintage items you won’t find anywhere else locally. As one happy customer put it, “My go-to for outfitting my Shore house in vintage beach chic style on a budget!”

17. Long Branch Consignment – Long Branch

Long Branch Consignment is located at 330b Morris Ave in Long Branch. Their hours are Tuesday-Saturday from 11am-5pm.

This upscale clothing consignment shop features contemporary women’s apparel, shoes, handbags, and accessories. Expect to find premium brands and styles, with new items added weekly.

As a consignment store, pricing is discounted 30-50% off estimated retail price. The atmosphere is clean and boutique-like, with items neatly organized by category, style, size, and color.

According to reviews, Long Branch Consignment is ideal for scoring discounted deals on fashionable brands while vacationing along the Jersey Shore. One delighted shopper said, “My go-to for contemporary styles in Long Branch!”

More Noteworthy Thrift Stores in New Jersey

18. The Society of St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store – Jersey City

The Society of St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store has two Jersey City locations – 641 Newark Ave open Monday-Saturday 9am-3pm and 437 Central Ave open Monday & Thursday-Saturday 9am-2pm.

These non-profit thrift shops carry clothing, shoes, furniture, kitchenware, toys, books, home goods, and more. Pricing is extremely affordable, with items priced at just a few dollars each. Sales are held frequently.

Proceeds from purchases fund the Society’s community outreach programs providing food, housing, and more to those in need. The stores have a straightforward layout with merchandise sorted neatly by category.

According to Google reviews, these no-frills mission-driven shops are perfect for uncovering amazing bargains in Jersey City. As one happy customer put it, “Hidden gem with bottom barrel prices!”

19. Treasure Mart – East Hanover

Treasure Mart is located at 220 Route 10 West in East Hanover, NJ. They are open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am-5pm.

This discount store carries new housewares, small appliances, toys, sporting goods, pet supplies, and more that has been donated by New Jersey retailers and businesses. Pricing is extremely affordable, with most items just a few dollars.

New stock arrives weekly, so there is always something new to uncover. The merchandise is all brand new condition and the store is neatly organized by category. Proceeds benefit Eva’s Village, helping the homeless in Passaic County.

According to Yelp reviews, savvy shoppers love the incredibly low prices on brand new surplus goods. As one pleased customer said, “Amazing deals to be found here if you hunt – all benefiting a great cause!”