Cleveland has become a top destination for thrifting and vintage finds. With over 20 excellent thrift stores scattered throughout the city and suburbs, you’re sure to uncover hidden gems and rare treasures. From boutique consignment shops to massive warehouses, these are the 21 best thrift stores in Cleveland.

Why Thrifting in Cleveland is So Popular

Thrifting has seen a major resurgence in recent years, and Cleveland boasts a vibrant thrifting culture. Here’s why thrifting is so popular in Cleveland:

• Affordability – Compared to normal retail prices, thrift stores offer unbeatable deals on high-quality items. You can easily furnish an entire home or revamp your wardrobe on a budget.
• Variety – Cleveland thrift stores carry an eclectic mix of merchandise. You never know what unique vintage, retro, or antique finds you’ll discover each visit.
• Sustainability – Shopping at thrift stores keeps used goods in circulation and out of landfills. It’s one of the most eco-friendly ways to shop.
• Community – Many local thrift stores give back proceeds to charities and community programs. Thrifting supports these important initiatives.
• The Thrill of the Hunt – Thrifting is an exciting treasure hunt. There’s a rush searching the shelves to uncover a one-of-a-kind prize.

The Best Thrift Stores in Cleveland for Clothing & Accessories

Looking for secondhand apparel and accessories? Check out these top 10 Cleveland thrift stores:

1. Buffalo Exchange

Location: 11824 Detroit Ave, Cleveland, OH 44107

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 8pm, Sunday 11am – 6pm

Buffalo Exchange stocks stylish vintage and current-season clothing for men and women. With two floors of merchandise, they have an expansive selection ranging from jeans, jackets, sweaters, dresses, rompers, T-shirts, shoes, bags, belts, hats, and jewelry.

They carefully curate their inventory and only accept the best quality designer items in contemporary styles. Items are organized neatly by size and type.

Prices are moderate compared to thrift stores, but you can expect to find brands like Madewell, Free People, Urban Outfitters, and Anthropologie for up to 70% off retail. The atmosphere is bright and spacious. Buffalo Exchange also buys clothing from the public, making it easy to refresh your wardrobe.

2. Crossroads Trading Company

Location: 3794 W 140th St, Cleveland, OH 44111

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 9pm, Sunday 11am – 7pm

Crossroads buys and sells lightly used brand-name apparel, with a focus on gear for teens, young adults, and beyond. Expect to find an excellent selection of sweatshirts, flannels, jackets, joggers, jeans, shorts, logo tees, shoes, and accessories from brands like Nike, Adidas, Champion, Levi’s, American Eagle, Abercrombie, Hollister, Vans, Converse and more.

They also carry unique vintage graphic tees, many priced under $10. The bright, organized store has new merchandise put out daily so there’s always something fresh to discover. As a bonus, Crossroads trades clothing – you can bring in gently used items for cash or 60% more in trade credit.

3. Uptown Cheapskate

Location: 6169 Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH 44124

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 9pm, Sunday 11am – 7pm

Uptown Cheapskate specializes in “cheap with style” clothing and accessories for teens, young adults, and moms. They carry all the latest styles from brands like H&M, Forever 21, Zara, Steve Madden, Guess, Calvin Klein, Adidas and more.

Expect to find jeans, leggings, sweatshirts, flannels, jackets, dresses, rompers, shoes, handbags, and jewelry neatly organized by size, style, and color. Compared to other resale stores, prices at Uptown Cheapskate are extra budget-friendly, with most items under $20.

The store even buys clothing from customers – you’ll get 60% cash or 80% trade credit for accepted items. Uptown Cheapskate also has a student discount program.

4. Plato’s Closet

Location: 26298 Detroit Rd, Westlake, OH 44145

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 9pm, Sunday 11am – 6pm

Plato’s Closet is the perfect thrift store for teens and twenty-somethings looking for cheap, stylish clothing and accessories. They carry all the latest apparel from popular mall brands like American Eagle, Hollister, Abercrombie & Fitch, Old Navy, Gap, Guess, and J.Crew, as well as shoes, handbags, sunglasses, jewelry, belts, and other accessories.

The store is neatly organized by size, style, and color, making it easy to browse. Expect to find a great selection of on-trend jeans, graphic tees, sweatshirts, flannels, dresses, shorts, swimwear, outerwear, loungewear, and more for up to 70% off retail prices. Plato’s Closet also buys and trades gently used clothing.

5. Pop’N Tags Thrift Boutique

Location: 11500 Lorain Ave, Cleveland, OH 44111

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 8pm, Sunday 12pm – 6pm

Pop’N Tags Thrift Boutique gets rave reviews for its amazing selection of vintage and current women’s clothing and accessories at reasonable prices. The bright boutique is nicely organized by size, style and color. Expect to uncover designer brands like Anthropologie, BCBG, Calvin Klein, Michael Kors, Free People, Lucky Brand and more.

Pop’N Tags has trendy tops, pants, jeans, sweaters, jackets, shoes and accessories as well as a nice selection of formal wear. The dressing rooms are clean and spacious so you can try items on comfortably. Many customers report finding high-end items for bargain prices here. Pop’N Tags also buys clothing from the public.

6. Take2 Boutique

Location: 34717 Aurora Rd, Solon, OH 44139

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 6pm

At Take2 Boutique expect to uncover designer brands like Michael Kors, Coach, Kate Spade, Tory Burch, Eileen Fischer, Anthropologie, Sundance and more at 50-90% off retail prices. They stock a nice range of contemporary women’s clothing in classic, trendy, and professional styles in sizes XS to XL.

Separates like skirts, pants, tops, and sweaters abound, along with dresses, outerwear, handbags, wallets, jewelry, belts, scarves and shoes. The upscale boutique has new inventory put out daily. Items are attractively displayed by color and type.

Friendly staff provide excellent customer service. Take2 also accepts consignments from the public with 45% cash/55% store credit offered.

7. Flower Child

Location: 11512 Clifton Blvd, Cleveland, OH 44102

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11am – 7pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Flower Child has a nicely curated collection of vintage, Bohemian, and contemporary women’s clothing, shoes, and jewelry at reasonable prices. Expect to find flowy maxi dresses, peasant blouses, cardigans, flared jeans, jumpsuits, overalls, kimonos, funky printed pants, leggings, tunics, tanks, sweaters, faux fur coats, and more.

The vibe is laid back and creative. There is also a nice selection of handmade jewelry, handbags, hats, and belts to complement the unique apparel. Flower Child’s sizable dressing room lets you try items on comfortably. Regular customers rave about the quality and affordability of this Cleveland gem.

8. Avalon Exchange

Location: 19014 Old Detroit Rd, Rocky River, OH 44116

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 6pm

Avalon Exchange carries affordable upscale women’s apparel, handbags, and shoes in sizes XS to XL. Expect to find popular brands like J.Crew, Banana Republic, Ann Taylor, Chico’s, White House Black Market, Loft, Talbots, and Coldwater Creek.

The boutique has a classic to contemporary style with lots of options for work or going out. Tops, pants, skirts, dresses, outerwear, jewelry, and accessories are neatly displayed by color and size. Most items are just $5-10 with new inventory put out daily. The dressing room is roomy. Avalon Exchange also accepts consignments from the public with 50% cash/50% store credit offered.

9. The RealReal

Location: 20065 Lake Rd, Rocky River, OH 44116

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11am – 6pm, Appointment Only

The RealReal sells authenticated luxury consignments including sought-after designers like Chanel, Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Prada, Christian Louboutin, Cartier, and more. Appointments are required to shop. The upscale boutique carries women’s apparel, shoes, jewelry and handbags.

Expect to find cocktail dresses, gowns, blouses, ski jackets, pants, shoes, and purses in pristine, like-new condition from contemporary and vintage luxury brands. There are real gems to be found here if you have a designer budget. Items can be 40 – 60% off retail prices. The RealReal also consigns luxury goods from the public.

10. Chelsea’s Consignments

Location: 16133 Detroit Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 7pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Chelsea’s Consignments offers women’s designer clothing, handbags, jewelry, and accessories from contemporary brands like Free People, J.Crew, Anthropologie, BCBG, and Calvin Klein as well as vintage items.

The boutique has an excellent selection of casual and business wear including pants, tops, dresses, skirts, jeans, shorts, blazers, shoes, belts, scarves, and more in sizes 0 to 18. Items are attractively displayed by size, style, and color. Many regulars rave about the designer finds at bargain prices here. Chelsea’s also buys clothing, taking 40% cash/60% store credit on accepted items.

11. Common Threads Thrift Store

Location: 7820 Detroit Ave, Cleveland, OH 44102

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 6pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Common Threads Thrift Store benefits local charities through its sales of clothing, accessories, shoes, jewelry, handbags, belts, and hats. The nonprofit store carries contemporary and vintage styles for women, men, juniors and kids. Expect to find popular brands like Nike, Gap, H&M, J.Crew, Calvin Klein, Levi’s and more.

Merchandise is neatly organized by size and type. There’s an extensive selection of jeans, tops, jackets, sweaters, tees, dresses, outerwear, loungewear, costume jewelry and other accessories priced affordably.

Changing rooms allow you to try items on. Common Threads has 50% off sales every Wednesday to offer even better deals. Proceeds fund healthcare, youth mentoring, animal rescue, and other community programs.

12. Goodwill Industries of Greater Cleveland & East Central Ohio

Locations: Over 20 locations across Cleveland, Akron and Canton

Hours Vary By Location

Goodwill has bargain clothing, shoes, accessories, furniture, electronics, books, artwork, housewares, and home decor at affordable prices, with new inventory put out daily. Local Goodwill stores are clean, well-organized, and stocked with a wide variety ranging from current brand name apparel and goods to antiques and collectibles.

As a bonus, shopping at Goodwill helps fund their job training programs for people facing challenges to employment. Some customers specifically visit Goodwill stores in wealthier neighborhoods to find high-end donated items. Be sure to ask about any current sales or specials to get the best deals.

13. Savers

Locations:

• 29020 Lorain Rd, North Olmsted, OH 44070
• 5591 Warrensville Center Rd, Maple Heights, OH 44137

Hours Vary By Location

Savers is a discount thrift chain with two large Cleveland locations carrying clothing, shoes, accessories, furniture, books, electronics, collectibles, artwork, and home goods. Expect to find current fast fashion along with vintage and retro styles.

The bright stores are neatly merchandised by category. Savers has 50% off sales every Wednesday on select colors to offer extra bargains. They frequently post sneak peeks of inventory on social media. Proceeds benefit Big Brothers Big Sisters youth mentorship. Shopping here supports this worthwhile cause.

The Best Thrift Stores in Cleveland for Furniture & Home Goods

Transforming your home? Hit up these top Cleveland thrift stores to uncover secondhand furniture and home decor at a fraction of retail prices.

1. Sweet Lorain Antiques

Location: 30703 Lorain Rd, North Olmsted, OH 44070

Hours: Wednesday – Saturday 11am – 6pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Sweet Lorain Antiques houses over 55 individual antique dealers showcasing vintage furniture, china, glassware, lighting, rugs, art, quilts, clocks, toys, sports memorabilia, comics, jewelry, dolls, holiday collectibles, and more across three floors.

Expect to find Victorian, Art Deco, Midcentury Modern, primitive country, industrial and retro styles. The sprawling 30,000-square-foot warehouse is packed with treasures spanning decades.

Allow plenty of time to wander the aisles here – some favorite booths include Grandma’s Attic (vintage kitchenware), Fool’s Gold Mine (sports collectibles), and Memory Lane (vintage toys). Dealers are friendly and prices are reasonable. Be sure to grab a map at the front entrance to help navigate this home decor paradise.

2. Lakewood Antique Mall

Location: 13000 Athens Ave, Lakewood, OH 44107

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 6pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Lakewood Antique Mall houses over 100 antique dealers within a 12,000-square-foot historic theater building. Find a diverse treasure trove of merchandise including furniture, china, pottery, linens, lighting, artwork, jewelry, coins, dolls, quilts, cameras, toys, glassware, and vintage holiday decor.

Midcentury Modern, Art Deco, industrial, and Victorian styles abound. The mall is clean, well-organized and fairly priced.

Favorites like Grandma’s Kitchen (vintage tableware), Coins & Jewels, and Hollywood Nostalgia (classic movie memorabilia) keep shoppers hunting the rows for hours. The building itself is an attraction with its original 1920s terra cotta facade and sparkling chandeliers.

3. Habitat for Humanity ReStore

Locations:

• 3720 E. 65th St, Cleveland, OH 44105
• 22305 Brookpark Rd, Fairview Park, OH 44126

Hours:

• Cleveland – Monday – Saturday 9am – 6pm
• Fairview – Tuesday – Saturday 10am – 6pm

Habitat for Humanity ReStores has quality new and used home furnishings, appliances, hardware, construction materials, and more at 50-80% off retail pricing. The large stores carry everything for home remodeling projects including cabinets, countertops, lighting, bath fixtures, doors, windows, flooring, and tile as well as furniture, artwork, rugs, housewares, and some vintage collectibles.

New merchandise like surplus and closeout building supplies arrive daily. Purchases support Habitat for Humanity’s mission to build affordable housing locally. Many thrifty shoppers love the remarkable savings they find outfitting homes at ReStore.

4. Cache Resale Shop

Location: 33515 Aurora Rd, Solon, OH 44139

Hours: Monday – Saturday 10am – 6pm

Cache Resale Shop has an impressive collection of gently used contemporary, vintage, and antique home furnishings and decor. Expect to find couches, chairs, coffee and end tables, beds, dressers, desks, shelving, artwork, mirrors, lamps, area rugs, and home accessories.

The 7,000-square-foot showroom is clean, spacious, and organized for easy browsing. New inventory arrives daily, and seasonal rooms like the Christmas Shop get updated regularly.

Furniture pricing is very reasonable – the store claims to beat any competitor’s prices. The cache also consigns high-end furnishings and art. It’s a favorite among interior designers and thrifty homeowners furnishing on a budget.

Top Thrift Stores in Cleveland for Rare Finds & Hidden Gems

For a true treasure hunt, explore these off-the-beaten-path Cleveland thrift stores. Prepare to meander through the stacks and uncover some rare gems.

1. Eclectic Eccentric

Location: 11411 Detroit Ave, Cleveland, OH 44102

Hours: Monday – Sunday 10am – 6pm

Eclectic Eccentric houses over 50 quirky vendors selling an endless array of funky furniture, oddities, kitsch, concert t-shirts, toys, books, vinyl records, jewelry, art, and more across three floors. The 12,000-square-foot store is packed to the brim with curiously unorthodox merchandise spanning decades.

Prepare to spend hours digging through surprising finds. Customer favorites include Big Daddy’s Place (vintage toys), Rock n Roll Heaven (band tees and memorabilia), and Retro Furnishings (distinctive decor).

Prices are reasonable and the helpful staff love talking about unique treasures. Don’t miss this wonderfully weird warehouse of curiosities.

2. Eccentric Eclectic II

Location: 19905 Detroit Rd, Rocky River, OH 44116

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11am – 7pm, Sunday 12pm – 5pm

Get even more variety at Eccentric Eclectic II, billed as Cleveland’s “Most Unusual Store.” Across two floors, over 100 consignment vendors fill the shop with everything from concert posters to mid-century decor.

Let your curiosity guide you through merchandise neatly organized by category. Beyond furniture, shop home goods, art, books, sports memorabilia, comics, antiques, concert t-shirts, vintage toys, and video games. The sheer diversity of goods makes every visit an adventure.

Customer favorites include Cassette Culture (music), Figments of Imagination (sci-fi/fantasy), and Mongolian BBQ (vintage Asian decor). You’ll never know what you’ll uncover in this emporium’s maze of merchandise.

3. Frugal Fortunes

Location: 5 Divide Ave, Suite C, Akron, OH 44301

Hours: Monday – Saturday 11am – 7pm

Frugal Fortunes houses an extensive collection of rare books, vintage vinyl records, jewelry, vintage action figures, rock n roll/concert tees, samurai swords, and oddities across two floors and 13,000 square feet. It’s one of the most eclectic thrift stores in the Cleveland area.

Spend hours sorting through their diverse wares. Favorites like Deadhead Memorabilia and Retro Gaming dens satisfy niche interests. The helpful staff loves connecting customers with hidden gems – be sure to ask if you need help uncovering any specific treasures.

Frugal Fortunes offers great prices on items in good condition. Check their social media for sneak peeks of inventory. This is a must-visit store for thrill seekers.

4. Highland Throwbacks

Location: 481 W. Highland Rd, Macedonia, OH 44056

Hours: Tuesday – Saturday 12pm – 7pm

Highland Throwbacks specializes in throwback sports gear, vinyl records, cassettes, VHS tapes, and music memorabilia from the 50s-90s. They also buy retro items. Athletic jerseys, jackets, pennants, cards, and equipment fill their sports nooks.

The music alcove houses vinyl records, cassettes, music magazines, vintage concert tees, and more. Everything is neatly organized for easy digging. Prices are reasonable compared to vintage stores.

Beyond buying, customers rave about selling old sports treasures and LPs here. Got any old team jerseys or vintage vinyl lying around? Bring it to Highland Throwbacks for cash or trade credit. This local favorite resurrects old-school nostalgia.

The History of Thrifting in Cleveland

Thrift stores first emerged in Cleveland in the early 1900s, with charitable organizations like Goodwill opening shops to fund programs supporting people in need. In subsequent decades, church-run thrift stores also opened to benefit local community initiatives.

Over the years, thrifting has continued to hold an important place in Cleveland culture. Vintage shops like Sweet Lorain Antiques formed in the 1970s during a renewed interest in antiques. More recently, thrift stores have benefited the environmentally-conscious seeking secondhand goods.

What makes Cleveland a uniquely vibrant city for thrifting is the sheer variety of quality stores, from massive warehouses like Goodwill Outlet to curated boutiques like Flower Child Vintage. Clevelanders also take pride in thrifting as a way to creatively repurpose goods while benefiting community causes. The city’s thrift culture appears as strong as ever.

Thrifting Etiquette & Tips

Follow these guidelines to be a respectful and savvy thrifter:

• Treat the merchandise with care by not over-handling items or leaving things in disarray.
• Abide by any posted store policies around photography, restocking fees, etc.
• Keep your space tidy by refolding items neatly and returning things where you found them.
• Examine clothes, furniture and electronics closely for flaws prior to purchasing.
• To keep furniture hygienic for the next owner, consider wiping it down before buying.
• Understand each store’s return and exchange policies before making purchases.

Why Thrifting is Eco-Friendly

Thrifting reduces waste by giving used goods renewed life. Items donated to or bought by thrift stores avoid ending up in the landfill. By shopping secondhand, thrifters also avoid producing the pollution and waste associated with manufacturing new products.

Thrifting is the ultimate form of recycling and repurposing. Gently used clothes, furniture, home decor and other items are passed along rather than tossed out. Beyond being affordable, thrifting is one of the greenest ways to shop.

My Final Thoughts – Best Thrift Stores in Cleveland, Ohio

This guide highlighted 21 of the best thrift stores in Cleveland based on selection, quality and uniqueness. From boutique consignment to massive warehouses, Cleveland is a thrifter’s paradise. Whether you’re seeking stylish apparel, vintage furnishings or rare collectibles, you’re sure to find hidden gems in this city’s diverse range of secondhand shops.

We invite you to explore Cleveland’s excellent thrifting culture. Dive into the hunt for one-of-a-kind treasures you won’t find anywhere else.