Thrifting has become a popular trend, especially among millennials looking for affordable finds. And Jersey City, NJ has an amazing selection of thrift and consignment stores to discover treasures while sticking to a budget.

From major national chains like Goodwill and Salvation Army to local vintage boutiques, Jersey City has it all. You can find everything from luxury handbags to antique furniture as you thrift through the city’s diverse neighborhoods.

This guide will highlight the 18 best thrift shops in Jersey City and other consignment stores. You’ll find all the details on inventory, prices, store vibes, and more so you can plan your bargain hunting adventures. Let’s dive in!

Key Takeaways

The best thrift stores in Jersey City offer amazing deals while benefiting the community. Key takeaways include:

• Variety – From clothing to furniture, Jersey City has thrift and consignment for all styles and categories
• Vintage – For rare retro fashions, visit Revival Vintage and Vintage Thrift
• Designer – Find luxury brands at steep discounts at Rebag and Viyet
• Community – Support churches and charities by shopping at non-profits like Cure Thrift
• Volume – For huge selection, MyUnique Thriftique Warehouse can’t be beat
• Bargains – With some digging, uncover incredible deals on quality goods
• Giving Back – Thrifting also keeps items out of landfills and helps the community

Jersey City is a thrifting paradise with these best-of spots offering amazing deals for the savvy shopper.

Finding the Best Thrift Stores in Jersey City, New Jersey

Jersey City has exploded with great thrift and consignment options beyond your average Goodwill or Salvation Army. With vintage fashion, mid-century furniture, discount designer goods, and cheap used books, Jersey City has a fantastic selection of secondhand stores.

Thrifting is a treasure hunt – you never know what unique finds you’ll discover on each visit. It’s also an affordable way to refresh your wardrobe, redecorate your home, explore different styles, and keep clutter out of landfills by shopping secondhand.

Below I’ve compiled the top thrift stores in Jersey City covering a wide range of styles and specialties. I’ll give you an insider’s overview of each store so you can zero in on the ones that fit your tastes and budget as we look into some of the best thrift stores in New Jersey. Let’s get thrifty!

1. Salvation Army Thrift Store – 328 Central Ave

The Salvation Army is one of the most recognized thrift chains, with locations across the country. The Jersey City Salvation Army Thrift Store has a great selection of clothing, shoes, accessories, books, housewares, and furniture. Inventory comes from local donations.

As a charity shop, all proceeds go towards funding the Salvation Army’s community services and programs for those in need. Prices are very affordable, making this a go-to option for sticking to a budget.

Address: 328 Central Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307

Phone: (201) 659-4091

Website: https://www.salvationarmyusa.org

Hours: Mon-Sat 9am-7pm, Sun 10am-6pm

2. Goodwill Thrift Store – 654 Bergen Ave

Goodwill is another popular national thrift chain, with a massive location right in Jersey City. You’ll uncover amazing deals on clothing, furniture, books, household items, and more. Prices are cheap, yet the quality is often high since donations come from the local community.

As a non-profit, Goodwill aims to provide job training, education, and placement services for the community. Stop by this huge thrift store to find your next great bargain.

Address: 654 Bergen Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306

Phone: (201) 216-2253

Website: https://www.goodwillnynj.org

Hours: Mon-Sat 9am-9pm, Sun 10am-7pm

3. Buffalo Exchange – 332 3rd St

For trendy secondhand fashions, Buffalo Exchange is a top choice. This popular resale franchise carries women’s, men’s, and kid’s clothing reflecting current styles. The Jersey City location is neat and organized for a higher-end thrifting experience.

Buffalo Exchange only accepts certain contemporary brands and styles in excellent condition. As a consignment store, you can also sell your pre-approved wardrobe items for cash or shop credit. Expect to find brands like Madewell, Anthropologie, and Free People at discount prices!

Address: 332 3rd St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 217-0880

Website: https://buffaloexchange.com

Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-8pm, Sun 12pm-7pm

4. Revival Vintage – 333 Grove St

For shoppers seeking true vintage fashion, Revival Vintage is a retro paradise. You’ll uncover gorgeous jewelry, accessories, clothing, and footwear from the 1920s to 1980s. They have an eye for curating the best of fashion’s past eras.

The ambiance matches the vintage wares, with a quirky, old-school vibe. Prices vary by piece from affordable thrift finds to higher-end vintage. This spot is ideal for unique vintage statement pieces you won’t find anywhere else!

Address: 333 Grove St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 333-5733

Website: https://revivalvintagejc.com

Hours: Tues-Sun 12pm-7pm, Mon 12pm-6pm

5. Another Man’s Treasure – 351 3rd St

As the name suggests, Another Man’s Treasure has a fantastic selection of secondhand goods at cheap prices. Locals recommend this thrift shop for its extensive inventory spanning two floors.

You’ll find clothing, shoes, accessories, home decor, kitchenware, electronics, books, toys, and more. While selection changes quickly, sharp shoppers can find amazing deals on anything imaginable. Cash only.

Address: 351 3rd St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 217-1416

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Sat 10am-6pm, Sun 12pm-5pm

6. Vintage Thrift – 627 West Side Ave

Vintage Thrift lives up to its name with amazing finds from past eras. Their collection focuses specifically on rare vintage clothing, jewelry, and ornate furniture. Prepare to uncover unique statement pieces from the 1920s through the 1980s.

As a true vintage shop, expect higher pricing than a basic thrift store but lower than full vintage retail. Pop into this off-the-beaten-path treasure trove for vintage fashions and decor you won’t find anywhere else.

Address: 627 West Side Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07304

Phone: (201) 798-0005

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Sat 10am-5pm, Sun 12pm-4pm

7. Cure Thrift Shop – 555 Bergen Ave

Cure Thrift Shop is a unique local charity shop aiming to help the community. All proceeds go to local organizations supporting healthcare, education, veterans, domestic violence shelters, disability services, homeless shelters, and more.

They have a nice selection of bargain clothing, shoes, books, baby items, small furniture, and household goods. Prices are cheap, yet the quality is much higher than a basic thrift store. A great spot for conscious shopping while benefiting a good cause!

Address: 555 Bergen Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07304

Phone: (201) 239-7387

Website: https://curethriftshopjc.org

Hours: Tues-Sat 10am-5pm

8. MyUnique Thriftique Warehouse – 888 Newark Ave

The name says it all – MyUnique Thriftique Warehouse is massively unique. Located in Jersey City’s Warehouse District, they occupy 35,000 square feet of a former fabric warehouse. This is thrifting on a grand scale!

Beyond clothing, MyUnique has overstock merchandise, household items, furniture, toys, books, and more all for unbelievably cheap. Think thrift prices starting at 50 cents. Be prepared to dig through their vast inventory spanning two floors. For huge selection across all categories, this thrift warehouse can’t be beat.

Address: 888 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306

Phone: (201) 915-2450

Website: https://myuniquethriftique.com

Hours: Mon-Fri 10am-7pm, Sat 10am-6pm, Sun 11am-5pm

9. Family Thrift Center – 235 Franklin St

Family Thrift Center is another local Jersey City charity shop where all proceeds support families in need and community programs. They have a nice selection of clothing, accessories, shoes, toys, appliances, furniture, and household items priced affordably.

As donations come directly from the Jersey City community, you’ll often spot quality pieces and gems for bargain prices if you dig. An excellent thrift spot supporting a great cause!

Address: 235 Franklin St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 333-2955

Website: https://familythriftcenter.org

Hours: Mon-Sat 9:30am-5pm

10. Second Time Around – 182 Newark Ave

Second Time Around offers an eclectic mix as a family-owned thrift and consignment shop. Comb through their inventory spanning clothing, antiques, furniture, jewelry, art, music, and home decor. Prices vary based on item condition and rarity.

The owners have a knack for curation, so expect to spot rare vintage pieces mixed with secondhand gems across eras and styles. Follow them on social media for the latest finds hitting their store in the Grove Street neighborhood.

Address: 182 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 659-3322

Website: https://secondtimearound.shop

Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-6pm, Sun 12pm-5pm

11. King Buy Night Gallery – 557 Newark Ave

The eclectic finds continue at King Buy Night Gallery, both a thrift store and antique shop. Beyond everyday secondhand goods, they specialize in rare collectibles, vintage furniture, artwork, and oddities.

Expect a wide range of price points from bargain thrift up to $5,000+ for rare antiques. Local artists and vendors also sell goods here. Definitely one of Jersey City’s most unique and quirky thrifting destinations!

Address: 557 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306

Phone: (201) 659-1619

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-7pm, Sun 12pm-6pm

12. Rebag – 30 Hudson St

For thrifted designer and luxury goods, Rebag is unparalleled. As a high-end handbag reseller, they sell discounted pre-owned bags from brands like Chanel, Louis Vuitton, Hermes, and more. Beyond bags, they now also offer jewelry, accessories, watches, and clothes.

Their “Rebag Infinity” program allows you to sell back your Rebag purchases later. Expect savings up to 70% off retail for gently used luxury items in like-new condition. High-end thrifting at its finest!

Address: 30 Hudson St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (844) 690-4224

Website: https://shop.rebag.com

Hours: Mon-Wed 11am-7pm, Thurs-Sat 11am-8pm, Sun 12pm-6pm

13. Viyet – 94 Hudson St

For discount high-end furniture and home decor, Viyet offers an unrivaled selection of like-new luxury brands. As a premium consignment marketplace, you’ll find pieces from retailers like Restoration Hardware, CB2, Crate & Barrel, and West Elm up to 75% off retail price.

Beyond furniture, Viyet carries home decor, rugs, lighting, and more. Expect high-quality craftsmanship on contemporary as well as antique furnishings. Luxury home goods at thrift-level prices!

Address: 94 Hudson St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 500-6575

Website: https://viyet.com

Hours: Mon-Sat 10am-7pm, Sun 11am-6pm

14. Eclectiques – The Antique Collective – 351 3rd St

For antiquing with a vintage flair, Eclectiques is a top destination housing over 100 antique dealers and vendors. As a collective shop, you’ll uncover booths filled with diverse treasures from lighting to furniture to china and more across eras.

Expect higher price points for true antiques, but well below full retail. There are affordable deals to be had if you look! Bonus: it’s located beside Another Man’s Treasure thrift shop so you can make an antiquing day out of this location.

Address: 351 3rd St, Jersey City, NJ 07302

Phone: (201) 217-1412

Website: https://eclectiquesantiques.com

Hours: Sun-Thurs 12pm-7pm, Fri-Sat 11am-5pm

15. Gonzalez Clothing – 604 Newark Ave

Gonzalez Clothing offers affordable thrifted fashion spanning everyday wear to vintage finds. As a Latinx family-owned business, they hand select quality secondhand clothing and accessories with the neighborhood community in mind.

Expect to uncover women’s, men’s, and children’s clothing, shoes, hats, jewelry, and handbags priced cheap. Gonzalez is an excellent neighborhood spot for stylish thrifted outfits on a budget.

Address: 604 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306

Phone: (201) 946-1584

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Sat 10am-7pm, Sun 11am-6pm

16. Trap N Kix LLC – 572 Bergen Ave

For streetwear and urban fashions, Trap N Kix is a unique find. They specialize in secondhand street style clothing, shoes, and accessories with popular brands like Supreme, Bape, Off-White, and vintage Jordan sneakers.

Beyond streetwear, they also carry electronics, collectibles, jewelry, and antiques. With affordable prices compared to hype retail costs, this is the spot to thrift urban style and vintage grails.

Address: 572 Bergen Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07304

Phone: (201) 610-5209

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Sat 11am-7pm, Sun 12pm-6pm

17. Thriftique Warehouse – 888 Newark Ave

Thriftique Warehouse shares a massive space with MyUnique Thrift and carries an equally huge inventory spanning 35,000 square feet. Find aisle after aisle of clothing, shoes, accessories, furniture, housewares, books, toys, and electronics all at unbelievable prices.

As new inventory arrives daily from local donations, treasures are constantly waiting to be discovered. For a true thrift warehouse experience, plan to spend hours digging for deals across categories.

Address: 888 Newark Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07306

Phone: (201) 659-2205

Website: None

Hours: Mon-Fri 10am-5pm, Sat 10am-6pm, Sun 11am-5pm

18. St. Mary Thrift Shop – 20 Gilligan St

St. Mary Thrift Shop benefits Corpus Christi Church and their community outreach programs. Shoppers can find amazing deals on clothing, accessories, shoes, housewares, books, toys, and furniture with new stock daily.

As a charity shop, prices are dirt cheap while supporting a great cause. St. Mary’s is a neighborhood favorite for affordable finds year-round. Don’t miss their sidewalk sale every July!

Address: 20 Gilligan St, Jersey City, NJ 07304

Phone: (201) 653-1378

Website: None

Hours: Tues-Sat 10am-2:30pm

Tips for Thrifting in Jersey City

• Go often, even weekly, as inventory changes constantly
• Ask stores when they restock and put out new items
• Don’t ignore looking through shelves, bins, and racks thoroughly
• Searching by section helps target your categories of interest
• Knowing popular brands and labels helps identify hidden gems
• Negotiate prices for bundle deals or flaws/defects
• Bring your own reusable bags to reduce waste
• Carry cash for shops that don’t accept credit cards
• Avoid visiting right when stores open or on 50% off sale days

Benefits of Thrifting in Jersey City

• Save money on quality items compared to retail prices
• Find unique vintage and antique treasures not in stores
• Reduce waste and recycle by shopping secondhand
• Support local charities, churches, and community programs
• Discover items that reflect your unique personal style
• Hunt for rare collectibles, specialty items, and hidden gems
• Explore different neighborhoods and local businesses

Wrapping Up the Best Thrift Stores in Jersey City, NJ

Thrifting in Jersey City is the perfect blend of savings, selection, and community support. This guide highlighted the top spots to discover secondhand treasures across all categories.

• Hit up Salvation Army and Goodwill for everyday thrifted wares covering all your needs at bargain prices
• Seek out Revival Vintage and Vintage Thrift for rare vintage statement pieces transporting you to past eras
• Score major deals on discounted designer items at luxury resellers like Rebag and Viyet
• Support local charities and churches by shopping at community-focused consignment shops like Cure Thrift and St. Mary’s
• For an adventure, get lost in the massive inventories of MyUnique Thriftique Warehouse and Thriftique Warehouse

With this list of the best thrift stores in Jersey City, you can hunt for hidden gems while sticking to your budget and giving back to the community. Happy thrifting and enjoy the treasure hunt!