Thrifting has become an increasingly popular activity in Cincinnati for bargain hunters and vintage enthusiasts alike. There are many thrift stores in Cincinnati with such a wide variety of quality secondhand stores throughout the greater Cincinnati area, it’s no wonder thrifting has caught on here!

From major chains like Goodwill to local gems like New2You Uptown Thrift, Cincinnati is a haven for affordable shopping and vintage treasures.

Key Takeaways

Why Thrifting is Popular in Cincinnati

There are several key reasons thrifting has become such a popular pastime throughout Cincinnati:

• Affordability – Compared to regular retail prices, thrift stores allow you to buy clothing, furniture, household items and more at a fraction of the cost. Everything is pre-owned and discounted.
• Unique Finds – Thrifting is the perfect venue for finding those one-of-a-kind vintage and retro items you won’t see anywhere else. From funky printed shirts to mid-century modern decor, thrift stores are a treasure trove.
• Eco-Friendly – Shopping at secondhand stores is far more sustainable than buying new mass-produced items. It cuts down on waste and extends the life of quality goods.
• The Thrill of the Hunt – Many thrift shoppers simply love searching the racks and digging through piles to uncover that hidden gem or rare vintage find. It becomes addictive!
• Giving Back – Money spent at many local thrift shops benefits charities, churches, schools and other community organizations. Shopping thrift is a great way to support these groups.

The Best Thrift Stores in Cincinnati

From big chains to local gems, here is our list of the top and best thrift stores in Cincinnati to explore:

1. Goodwill – Cincinnati

The massive Goodwill store on Cincinnati’s west side is a thrift lover’s paradise. As one of the largest Goodwill locations in the area at over 50,000 square feet, it offers a wide selection of clothing, books, music, electronics, furniture, housewares and more.

Expect to find everything from current fast fashion styles to retro t-shirts. Make sure to check out their book collection as well, with over 15,000 titles in stock across fiction, non-fiction, textbooks, and children’s books.

This Goodwill is open 9am-9pm Monday through Saturday, and 10am-6pm on Sundays. They get new inventory shipments daily to keep the shelves freshly stocked. While some items are more expensive than other thrift stores, there are still plenty of deals to be found.

The store’s large size does mean more ground to cover, so be prepared to devote some time to searching the aisles. According to reviews, shoppers recommend going early in the day for the best selection.

Address: 1201 Race St, Cincinnati, OH 45202

2. New2You Uptown Thrift Store

Specializing in higher-end vintage and retro fashions, New2You Uptown Thrift is located in a cool exposed brick building in Cincinnati’s Hyde Park neighborhood. They carry stylish modern brands like Anthropologie and J.Crew along with plenty of fun unique statement pieces. Check out their wide array of funky printed button-ups, denim jackets, Hawaiian shirts, and accessories.

New2You is open from 10am-6pm daily. Prices are fair for the curated selection of upscale brands and vintage wares. The store frequently gets new inventory so repeat visits can uncover new items. Shoppers recommend browsing all the racks and shelves thoroughly to find the hidden gems. New2You also offers a student discount with a valid ID.

Address: 42 Calhoun St, Cincinnati, OH 45219

3. St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store and Donation Center

This large thrift shop features household items, clothing, books, toys, collectibles and more, with proceeds going to charity. As one of Cincinnati’s most popular thrift stores, many shoppers love the amazing deals they can find on everything from cookware to furniture. Definitely check out their rotating selection of antiques and vintage items like jewelry, glassware, and one-of-a-kind home decor.

St. Vincent de Paul is open Monday-Saturday 9am-6pm. They get daily donations so inventory is constantly changing. Prices are among the lowest in the city, making this a favorite with bargain hunters. Shoppers recommend browsing slowly and carefully, as treasures can be tucked away anywhere. The store also frequently runs special sales events.

Address: 1175 Bank St, Cincinnati, OH 45214

4. Valley Thrift Store

Boasting affordable prices, Valley Thrift Store is another top destination for thrifters. Peruse aisles stuffed with books, toys, home accessories, and clothes. They have a particularly good vintage and retro section – be sure to browse their collection of unique tees and sweaters as well as glassware and kitschy decor.

Valley Thrift is open Monday-Saturday from 9am-8pm, and Sundays 11am-5pm. They get daily donations and restock the sales floor constantly. Prices range from 50 cents to a few dollars for most items. Shoppers recommend checking the clothing racks frequently, as hot items go quickly. Going later in the day tends to offer the best discounts.

Address: 10500 Reading Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45241

5. Clothes Mentor

Focusing specifically on women’s apparel and accessories, Clothes Mentor sells new and gently used brand name styles at up to 70% off retail prices. Expect to find pieces from brands like LOFT, J.Crew, Anthropologie and more. They also carry shoes, handbags and jewelry.

Operating 10am-8pm Monday-Saturday and 12pm-6pm on Sundays, Clothes Mentor offers a clean and organized shopping environment. The stock rotates often, with new arrivals daily. Shoppers recommend stopping by frequently as inventory is always changing. Prices are affordable while still offering major brand names. Trying on items is encouraged to ensure proper fit.

Address: 3880 Paxton Ave E, Cincinnati, OH 45209

6. Goodwill Outlet – Evendale

The Goodwill Outlet in Evendale offers a unique thrifting experience with bins of clothing and other miscellaneous items that shoppers can sift through. Prices are based on the pound, allowing thrifters on a budget to potentially score major deals. The selection ranges from clothes to books, housewares, toys, and more. The stock is constantly changing as bins are rolled in and out throughout the day.

This massive outlet store is open Monday-Saturday 9am-6pm. There is a $1 entrance fee on Saturdays. Veterans and military families get 50% off on Wednesdays. Be prepared to dig as you never know what hidden finds you may uncover. Reviewers recommend wearing gloves for the bin digging and checking out often as stock rotates quickly.

Address: 11340 Century Circle E, Cincinnati, OH 45246

7. Legacy Thrift

With two large Cincinnati locations, Legacy Thrift is a local favorite for its quality selection and affordable prices. From clothing to furniture and everything in between, you never know what unique treasures you may find here. They get new stock daily, both from public donations and store buys. Legacy frequently runs special sales as well.

The hours at the Cincinnati locations are 9am-9pm Monday-Saturday and 10am-6pm on Sunday. Given the large inventory, reviewers suggest taking your time to comb through everything. The clothing selection ranges from current fast fashion brands to retro and vintage pieces. The Legacy stores also have several brand partnerships to sell new excess stock items at thrift prices.

Address: 5707 Red Bank Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45227 and 1690 Tennessee Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45229

8. Hyde Park Platz Thrift Shop

Run by the Junior League of Cincinnati, this upscale resale store features clothing, accessories, furniture and home goods. Designer brands are well-represented at reasonable prices. The Platz frequently gets new consignment furniture as well, from vintage to modern styles. As a charity shop, proceeds go to support projects benefiting women, children and families.

The Platz is open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am to 5pm. Prices are fair for the quality of the merchandise. Shoppers recommend browsing slowly to uncover hidden designer pieces and unique decor items. As a smaller boutique store, inventory is selective but rotated often. Check the sales racks for additional discounts.

Address: 2700 Erie Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45208

9. Casablanca Vintage

As the name implies, Casablanca Vintage is the go-to spot in Cincinnati for quality retro and vintage fashion. From funky printed shirts to flirty dresses, most pieces at Casablanca are curated from the 40s-90s. They also carry some new items that fit the vintage aesthetic. The shop has a quaint, almost museum-like feel. Beyond clothing, Casablanca also sells vintage jewelry, hats, purses and other accessories.

Casablanca is open from 11am-6pm Wednesday through Saturday and 12pm-4pm on Sunday. While pricier than a traditional thrift store, the vintage items are unique. Shoppers recommend trying things on, as older sizes run differently. Check Casablanca’s Instagram for special events and new arrivals.

Address: 3510 Edwards Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45208

10. Peppermint Pig Thrift Store

Attached to the Peppermint Pig animal rescue shelter, this thrift store sells clothing, accessories, antiques, books, housewares and eclectic vintage goods. All proceeds go to medical care for the shelter’s cats and dogs awaiting adoption. Beyond thrifting, you can also check out adoptable pets at the shelter. The merchandise is a mix of donated and purchased items.

The Peppermint Pig is open Wednesday-Friday 12pm-5pm and Saturday-Sunday 12pm-4pm. It’s staffed entirely by volunteers. Prices range from 50 cents to a few dollars for most items. Shoppers recommend checking all areas of the store as inventory moves around frequently. They also suggest bringing cash for the best deals.

Address: 4085 Kellogg Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45226

11. Cancer Support Community Resale Shop

With two locations in Fairfield and Blue Ash, the Cancer Support Community Resale Shop benefits cancer patients and their families. Beyond funding programs and services, the shops also offer free items like wigs and headwear for those going through treatment. The inventory ranges from clothing to furniture, household items, jewelry, antiques and books.

The Blue Ash store hours are Monday-Saturday 10am-6pm, while the Fairfield location is open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am-5pm. Shoppers recommend looking through everything, as unique treasures can be uncovered. Prices are reasonable, especially for the charity mission. The two shops also frequently run special sales promotions.

Address: 4626 Dixie Hwy, Fairfield, OH 45014 and 4350 Malsbary Rd, Blue Ash, OH 45242

12. Goodwill – Oakley

Another sizeable Goodwill location, the Oakley store offers an expansive selection of clothing, accessories, shoes, books, music, furniture and home goods spread out over two floors. Given its sizable inventory, shoppers are likely to uncover great bargains and rare finds here. Be sure to browse through the entire store for hidden gems. Goodwill Outlet bins are also on site to sift through.

This Goodwill is open 9am-9pm Monday-Saturday and 10am-6pm on Sundays. Reviewers recommend avoiding weekends when it can get busy. Ask about any current sales or special promotions as well. The wide selection means filtering through quite a bit of inventory, so make sure to take your time browsing each section thoroughly.

Address: 3709 Isabella Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45209

13. Treasure Aisles Flea Market

For a true treasure hunt experience, head to the Treasure Aisles Flea Market. With over 400 vendors peddling wares across two large buildings, you never know what you might find here. From antiques to collectibles, vintage goods, clothing, tools, and everyday household items, the variety is endless. Be sure to negotiate on prices as vendors expect haggling. Cash is preferred.

Treasure Aisles is open Friday-Sunday from 9am to 5pm. Admission is $2 on Friday and Saturday, while Sundays are free entry. Given the size of this flea market, expect to spend a few hours here if you want to cover all the ground. Reviewers recommend wearing comfortable shoes and bringing small bills for purchases. They also suggest arriving early as the best items go fast.

Address: 320 N Garver Rd, Monroe, OH 45050

14. Dress for Success Cincinnati Boutique

Focusing specifically on workwear essentials for women, Dress for Success Cincinnati carries both new and gently used professional attire donated by the community. Their mission is to empower unemployed and underemployed women with interview clothes as they re-enter the workforce. Beyond workwear, the boutique also offers career development programs.

The Dress for Success Cincinnati Boutique is open Tuesday-Saturday from 10am to 5pm. Appointments are required for shopping and services. Shoppers recommend calling ahead to schedule a time to browse the racks and dressing rooms in the bright, welcoming space. For those looking to give back, the boutique also accepts donations of professional women’s clothing and accessories.

Address: 4623 Wesley Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45212

15. Ohio Valley Antique Mall

Boasting 65,000 square feet of antiques and collectibles, the Ohio Valley Antique Mall houses over 200 individual dealer booths. Spread across two expansive levels, the mall carries everything from jewelry to vintage toys, glassware, records, memorabilia, mirrors, books, artwork, and retro furniture. You’re bound to score some classic treasures here if you take the time to thoroughly browse.

The Ohio Valley Antique Mall is open daily 10am-6pm, except Sundays when they are open 12pm-5pm. Reviewers recommend bringing a notepad to jot down booths you’d like to re-visit once you’ve scoped the entire mall. They also suggest negotiating with vendors, as many are willing to bargain on pricing. Admission is free.

Address: 6402 Harrison Ave, Cincinnati, OH 45247

16. Village Discount Outlet

Stretching over 17,000 square feet, Village Discount Outlet lives up to its name by offering bargains on brand name clothing, shoes, accessories, housewares, books, toys, and electronics. Inventory is constantly changing week-to-week. Recent stock can include new clothing from the likes of Old Navy and Forever 21 for heavily discounted prices.

Village Discount Outlet is open Monday-Saturday 9am-9pm and Sunday 10am-6pm. Given the frequent influx of new merchandise, reviewers suggest visiting often to catch the latest deals and selection. The clothing is organized by size and type. Beyond the main floor, make sure to browse the basement level for even more eclectic finds.

Address: 4501 Red Bank Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45227

Tips for Shopping at Cincinnati Thrift Stores

To make the most of your thrifting adventures in Cincinnati, keep these tips in mind:

• Go on less busy days like weekdays to have more time browsing without crowds.
• Bring cash for the best deals since some shops give discounts for cash payments.
• Be prepared to try on clothing and check sizes as thrift store sizing can be inconsistent.
• Ask about return policies in case an item doesn’t work out. Many thrift shops do allow returns.
• Be thorough and search through all sections, racks, and shelves to find hidden treasures.

More Top Thrift Stores in Cincinnati

While our list covers the 17 top-rated thrift stores in the Cincinnati area, there are several more noteworthy shops to check out:

• City Gospel Mission Thrift Store – Clifton
• Thrift Mart – Florence
• Walnut Hills Thrift Store
• Blue Jean Nation – Northside
• Senior Services of Northern Kentucky – Erlanger

No matter which thrift stores you explore around Cincinnati, you’re sure to score some amazing bargains and finds. Happy thrifting!